- Etsy reported stronger-than-expected Q3 revenue and profits, beating analyst consensus estimates.
- Despite the positive earnings report, the company’s stock fell by 8% in the immediate aftermath.
- The sharp decline was triggered by a weak Q4 profit margin forecast and a significant drop in active buyers.
- The number of active buyers on the platform decreased by 3.55 million year-on-year, raising concerns about growth.
A Bitter Pill for Investors
Online marketplace Etsy (NASDAQ:ETSY) delivered a classic case of mixed signals with its third-quarter financial results. While the company celebrated beats on both revenue and profit, investors were quick to focus on a grim outlook, sending the stock tumbling by 8% to $68.85 immediately following the announcement. The market’s harsh reaction underscores a growing concern about the platform’s future growth trajectory.
Q3 Performance at a Glance
On the surface, Etsy’s third quarter looked impressive. The company announced revenue of $678 million, a 2.4% increase year-on-year and a solid 3.3% above analyst expectations of $656.6 million. The good news continued down the income statement, with a GAAP profit of $0.63 per share, smashing consensus estimates by a remarkable 21.1%. Adjusted EBITDA also came in strong at $171.9 million, surpassing the anticipated $164.7 million.
Why the Market Reacted Negatively
Weak Guidance Spooks Shareholders
The primary catalyst for the stock’s plunge was the company’s guidance for the fourth quarter. Etsy projected an EBITDA margin of 24%, a figure that fell significantly short of the 27% that Wall Street had been expecting. This lower-than-anticipated profitability forecast for the crucial holiday season signaled potential challenges ahead, spooking investors who prioritize future earnings potential.
The Shrinking Customer Base
Adding to the anxiety was a troubling trend in user metrics. As an online marketplace, Etsy’s health is fundamentally tied to its ability to attract and retain customers. The report revealed that the number of active buyers fell to 93.16 million, a decrease of 3.55 million (or 3.7%) from the same period last year. This decline suggests that Etsy is struggling with customer acquisition and retention, a critical issue for a platform that relies on network effects.
Over the last two years, the company’s active buyer count has remained largely flat, but this quarter’s drop indicates that recent initiatives have not yet succeeded in re-energizing user growth.
Finding the Silver Lining
While the declining buyer count is a major red flag, Etsy did show strength in its ability to monetize its existing users. The average revenue per buyer (ARPB) grew by 6.3% year-on-year to $7.28. This indicates that the remaining buyers are spending more on the platform, which has helped to offset the impact of the shrinking user base on total revenue. However, this trend is not sustainable without a healthy influx of new customers.
Ultimately, Etsy’s Q3 report serves as a stark reminder that for growth-oriented tech stocks, past performance is often less important than future promises. The strong earnings beat was completely overshadowed by a weak outlook and deteriorating user metrics, leaving investors to question whether the platform can overcome its current hurdles.
Image Referance: https://finance.yahoo.com/news/etsy-nasdaq-etsy-surprises-q3-114911897.html